Totally Cool Inc. has issued a recall for 68 ice cream products across 13 brands due to potential listeria contamination, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced on Monday.
The Owings Mills, Maryland-based company halted production and distribution of the affected ice cream items after FDA sampling revealed the presence of Listeria monocytogenes. No other products from Totally Cool are involved in this recall.
Recalled Ice Cream Products
- Friendly’s: 60 fl oz Celebration Ice Cream Cake, 40 fl oz Strawberry Krunch Ice Cream Cake; all dates between: 05/20/2024 to 05/28/2025; with plant code: 24-65, 24-0065, 2465, 240065 (Example: 05/20/25 15:30 24-65)
- Hershey’s Ice Cream: 38 fl oz vanilla and chocolate flavored ice cream cake, 110 fl oz vanilla and chocolate flavored ice cream cake, 4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Ice Cream Cones, 4 fl oz Cookies & Cream Polar Bear Ice Cream Sandwiches; all codes Between: 2305140 to 2405170 for cakes; 3174 to 4047 for cones; 2307187 to 2406163 for sandwiches (Example: 2405140 11:42)
- Jeni’s: 3.5 fl oz Chocolate Silk Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches, 3.5 fl oz Key Lime Pie Frozen Dessert, 3.5 fl oz Mint Chocolate Truffle Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches, 3.5 fl oz Triple Berry Tart Pie Ice Cream Sandwiches; all best by dates: 07/24/25 to 05/23/2026; all codes between: 23205 to 24144; with plant code: 2465 (Example: Best By: 05/23/2026 Lot 24144 07:03 2465)
- Cumberland Farms: Cumberland Farms Farmhouse Premium Ice Cream Sandwich Rich Vanilla 4 fl oz, Cumberland Farms Farmhouse Premium Ice Cream Sandwich Marvelous Mint 4 fl oz; all best by dates between: 11/30/25 to 12/04/25; with plant code: 2465 (Example: Best By: 12/05/2025 07:17 2465)
- ChipWich: 4 fl oz The Original Vanilla Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Sandwich 10 Club Pack, 3 Pack and 24 Pack; 16 fl oz Vanilla Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Pint; 16 fl oz Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream Pint; all best by dates between: 02/23/25 to 12/21/25 for sandwiches; 07/25/2024 to 01/27/2025 for pints; with plant code: 24-65, 24-0065
- The Frozen Farmer: 4 fl oz Elf On the Shelf Santa’s Cookies Ice Cream Sandwiches, 16 fl oz Elf On the Shelf Santa’s Cookies, 16 fl oz Strawberry Sorbet Pints, 16 fl oz Raspberry Sorbet Pints, 16 fl oz Orange Cream Frobert Pints, 16 fl oz Watermelon Sorbet Pints; all best by dates between: 09/04/25 to 12/07/25 for sandwiches; 09/05/25 to 07/30/26 for pints; with plant code: 24-65 (Example: Best By: 07/30/2026, 24-65 14:05)
The recalled ice cream was distributed nationwide and could be found in retail stores and through direct delivery services. As of now, no illnesses have been reported in connection with this recall.
